This classic country barn has been completely updated and is full of modern conveniences, country charm, and a lot of local history!  You will feel far away from it all as you look over the acres of land all around you but you’re actually very close to everything Catskills!


Sit on the deck or in the Adirondack chairs on the hill and get lost in the sunsets and the amazing mountain views!


The bedroom loft looks over the open living space and the modern furnishings blend in with the original barn wood, posts, and beams. The fully updated kitchen makes meals easy. Dine inside or on the back deck.

Skylights bring in the sun and invite you to see the clouds and the stars from every room!





  • Bedroom. Queen bed
  • Living Room. Couch unfolds to queen



  • $410.00/weekend or two consecutive nights
  • $125.00/additional night
  • $900.00/week


  • The cleaning fee is $70.00 which we ask you to leave at the house for housekeeping.





Please ask about monthly and seasonal rentals.

       Visit our Renter’s Information Page

  • Privacy
  • Amazing Mountain Views
  • Fire Pit
  • Grill- Charcoal provided
  • Outdoor Furniture
  • Deck
  • Huge lawn and open fields


  • Wood Stove – wood provided
  • Bright and Airy
  • Dishwasher
  • Smart TV
  • No Cable or Satellite
  • Blue Ray player
  • Wi-Fi
  • Land Line – local calls only
  • Some Cell Service




  • 7 minutes to Lyne Acres Barn
  • 10 minutes to Spillian
  • 15 minutes to The Roxbury Barn
  • 15 minutes to The Stone Tavern Farm
  • 20 minutes to The Inn at West Settlement


  • 15 minutes to Belleayre Mountain
  • 20 minutes to Plattekill Mountain


  • 10 minutes to Margaretville
  • 15 minutes to Roxbury
  • 5 minutes to Fleischmanns


  • Fleischmanns



  Please read our Renter Information page

The Great Gray Barn

The Great Gray Barn

1 Bedroom, 1 bath, sleeps 4

If the above calendar is not displaying properly, click here to see the Availability Calendar

If the above calendar is not displaying property, click here to see the availability calendar



Amazing space. The views of the mountains are perfect. Great fireplace. Super cozy and close to many of our favorite little Catskills towns. Jason and Phyllis do a great job of making you feel at home. Will be back again for sure.

Jason G. 12/30/17



AMAZING! The best kept secret in the Catskills!! 10 minutes to Belleayre and about 15 to Plattekill for skiing and tubing! Barn was clean and so spacious! Immaculate. Despite single digit temps we were cozy and warm! Wood burning stove was an awesome additional heat source! We can't wait to return!! Jason and Phyllis were super helpful!!

Noreen P. 12/28/17



The barn provided the perfect environment for a winter escape from NYC. The barn is very peaceful and quiet! Very secluded, not very many houses around. The deck offers spectacular views of the mountains.The rustic wood feel is so cozy and calming. We had the wood burning all day and night! We highly recommend this place to just get away and relax.

Joshua G. 12/26/17



What a lovely gem of a house! My husband and our 3-year old son spent a weekend in November there, but despite the short days and cold weather - our stay was definitely much more pleasant by choosing to stay at Jason and Plyllis's place. It's very cosy, extremely charming and having a fireplace in November was perfect! The house was clean, instructions very precise, and we hope we can come back there in the spring.

B.L. 11/25/17



Cozy and clean cabin/barn experience in a great area

Ben R. 11/4/17



Wonderful spot. Beautiful, simple, super clean, great views, quiet. Good for a couple who like rustic, romantic. Great hosts too!

Suzanne W. 10/11/17



My wife and I were looking for a secluded getaway weekend, and this was the perfect place for it. I highly recommend Jason and Phyllis’s place.

Anthony M. 10/20/17



The perfect getaway! Beautiful skies, warm fires and a cozy place. Perfect for a romantic vacation from the world!

Jesse L  9/3/17



Great location, great house, amazing views, and great hosts. This place is perfect for a weekend getaway. Has the ideal mix of isolation and accessibility. Thank you for a great time.

Jeffrey N. 9/14/17



My boyfriend and I absolutely loved this property! The barn was beautiful and the view matches it! I would highly recommend if you are looking for a serene getaway!

Sarah S. 8/20/17



The Great Grey Barn was exceptional!!! Distant views, open serene country space, and air and barn itself was breathtaking! Jason and Phyllis are the best hosts we have experienced in the Catskills so far. Thanks for letting us stay at this magical place!

Carrie P. 8/15/17



We booked a fairly last minute weekend trip for the Fourth of July and stumbled upon the Great Gray Barn. It had everything we wanted- open spaces - great views - and privacy. Overall it exceeded our expectations- we truly felt like we were "away from it all" but we were also just a quick drive to a ton of cute shops, incredible hiking / mountain views, and great restaurants. It's also a quick 30-40 minute drive to a great local brewery in Westkill! The house itself is big, cozy, and very clean- and view from the back porch is spectacular! Jason and Phylis were extremely friendly, attentive and even went out of their way to stop by and personally assist with a request. We definitely recommend and will be staying with them again!

Lauren M. 7/1/17

Pine Hollow Lodging

PO Box 10

Margaretville, NY 12455


P  845-586-1433

F  845-810-7777